To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we do not use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
This is legit my new favorite eyeliner. There are some pretty good liners that are also deep black and long lasting, but this is quite top tier especially for the price! Blows some more expensive liners out of the water. I don't get raccoon eyes with this and it IS possible to smudge this a bit for a softer look, but if you are careful and not rubbing your eyes or doing anything unnecessarily risky around the eyes, the liner does a great job staying! It is also a nicely deep shade. I haven't tried it on the waterline, but honestly the waterline is hard for any liner. After all, we aren't getting tattoos here :)
I bought this eyeliner because I was intrigued by the color and it did not disappoint. I tend to go for a dark purple or even eggplant but this is a very unique shade, almost like a cherry cola. It glides on nicely with a clean line. I love that it's dark yet not black - it makes it pop. Would def buy it again! ;)
I use this daily and have a slight lazy eye. Everything else I wear leaves eyeliner on my upper lid where the lid hits just under my brow and it's so aggravating! But this one does not! It's awesome! I buy this all the time! Love it! Lasts all day on my eyelid. It will smudge if you rub it too hard, but it stays on better than any other I've tried and I've tried a lot! Lasts in the rain but comes off in the shower (of course I'm rubbing my eyes tho).
I got this in brown hesitantly because darker color is too stark. The brown (that I usually can not wear) looks more like the slate color that suits me. The pencil glides on so smoothly but it does no last me "24 hours" but way less. My eyes are kind of oily so probably needed an eye primer to help. I like Revlon Colorstay everything and woud buy this pencil again. The little sharpener is good too, just don't roll the pencil out too far to sharpen-it's delicate. A softer smudger would be nice but it all works fine.