To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we do not use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
I love this kiss me heroine eyeliner. It is very smooth and draws on very easily without any smudging or tucking of the eyelid. I got the brown color and it’s very natural, suitable for every day wear. The formulation is not water proof but does last the whole day. It is also easy to remove with a cleanser and a towel.
I don't like to wear a thick sweep of eyeliner, so I ordered this brown-black liner with a .1 mm tip. The first thing I noticed was that it seemed more brown than brown-black, which is fine because I prefer brown. It did not even seem dark brown. Yes, the tip is thin, but I did not really think it was any thinner than other very fine-line liners that I use. As with most liners, you can make either a fine or a thicker line with this liner.
I was surprised when this product came with a California Proposition 65 warning on it, because it was not listed in the product description online. It needs to be, as required by U.S. law. Many people take those warnings very seriously. The warning is for Carbon Black.
One thing that I noticed was that you have to let this product dry for at least a full minute before doing any other blending on your eye, or this liner will smudge. Once it dries, it is there to stay. When I went to take it off, I tried to remove it with my normal oily eye makeup remover. It actually did not come off. I then tried just plain soap and water on a tissue, and it came off just fine. Just the opposite of what I would expect.
This seems like a nice liner, but I really do not think it offers anything special over any other fine-line liner that I have used. I do like that it is available in two different brown shades, as brown eyeliner can be difficult to find in a fine-line liner.
This is definitely a nice product. I would give the product 4 stars and would recommend it primarily to people who have a hard time finding brown fine-line eyeliner.